Once again, Abertay University invited Justice for Innocent Men Scotland (JIMS) to speak to Criminology students. But it has now U-turned and apologised after backlash. The Jute Journal interviewed Abertay students who voiced their opinions about JIMS.
The University hosted JIMS director Marsha Sturgeon and founder Kirsty McDermott to speak to students at a criminology lecture on 6 November. This was organised for the second time by Dr Stuart Waiton, Senior Lecturer in Sociology and Criminology at Abertay University.
When JIMS was invited to Abertay last year, a complaint was lodged with the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman (SPSO), and the university received over 300 complaints and pieces of feedback from students and members of the public.
After conducting a 5-month investigation, the university reported that the JIMS lecture was “appropriate in the context of this module” and none of the complaints was upheld.
After JIMS was invited for the second time, The Jute Journal (TJJ) interviewed students who have voiced their opinions about JIMS.
When asked to respond to Abertay’s previous statement that the lecture was “appropriate in the context of the module”. A student who wishes to stay anonymous responded:
“No. Your main priority is the students and their safety, and if they are willing to invite people who cause fear and alarm and inform no one about it. It’s like they don’t care about us students. They preach a lot about how Abertay is the number one university for student satisfaction, and then they go and throw things like this at you.”
Many students have been victims of gender-based violence and stated their concerns about JIMS being invited on campus. An anonymous student said that:
“I sent them [Abertay University] an email last year, because I am a victim and I said how it made me feel with JIMS being on campus. Obviously, they are well known for targeting victims of sexual abuse. We would have avoided the campus altogether that day.”
In agreement with this, another anonymous student said that:
“I wouldn’t even come on campus if I knew they were going to be here. They are inviting very dangerous people, and there aren’t enough safeguards in place at all. I have also been a victim, and we have to worry about getting harassed in case someone like that walks past us, if we are talking about something too loudly.”
Despite immense backlash last year, which included student protests and graffitied walls, JIMS came back the second time. Students feel that the university has given JIMS a national platform that is enabling them to speak out. An anonymous student stated:
“He [Stuart Waiton] is meant to ask the university for permission [to invite external speakers]. Everyone is. There is supposed to be a rigorous change in how guest speakers are brought into the university. So, he has obviously asked them [Abertay University], and they have approved it. They [JIMS] are such a small group, and Abertay’s giving them a massive platform for whatever reason.”
The Lecturer Stuart Waiton has been a controversial figure at Abertay for years. He has previously spoken at JIMS protests and regularly publishes academic research centred around feminist lobbying in the judicial system. An anonymous student said:
“I think JIMS and Waiton individually thrive off it [the publicity]. That man has not had enough of a background check. The way that he is behaving, it appears that he has his own agenda and is trying to promote groups like JIMS for his own benefit.
There can be instances where men have been wrongfully convicted of crimes they did not commit. In response to this, anonymous students said that:
“We understand there are instances where people have been wrongly convicted, but I do not think that is their [JIMS] agenda. There are better ways to go about it. It is totally understandable that people are wrongly convicted all the time, but there are better groups. There are better people.
Other students who wish to stay anonymous said:
“If you are protecting the innocent who are wrongly accused and convicted, then I think that is fine. Obviously, if you were to be protecting the guilty men, then that would be a different thing”
On 13 November, Abertay University Principal Prof. Liz Bacon issued a statement:
“Over the past week we have listened carefully to the concerns raised by students, staff and others in relation to the Justice for Innocent Men Scotland (JIMS) lecture held on campus and have taken time to reflect.
“It is clear that we got things wrong and on behalf of the University I want to apologise for the distress and upset that this matter has caused, particularly to survivors of rape and sexual abuse and harassment.”
Abertay has banned JIMS and their representatives from returning and admitted that “it is clear that our prior assessment of the group, its members, and its online operations did not go far enough”.
Despite this outcome, TJJ’s interviews make it clear that JIMS has never been wanted at Abertay University, and the University should reconsider who they hire. It is essential to keep students’ interests at the heart of Abertay’s operations.
Spotted a mistake? Email thejutejournal@dusamedia.com and we’ll look at it. Read our corrections policy.
