The Jute Journal

AI in Universities: A New “Digital Divide.”

A new “digital divide” is emerging between those who can use AI effectively and those who cannot, a University of Dundee expert has said. “The challenge is not whether people use AI, but how well they use it” said Dr Michael Crabb, Dundee University’s Head of Computing in the new Faculty of Science, Engineering, and Business. Dr Crabb says a…

A new “digital divide” is emerging between those who can use AI effectively and those who cannot, a University of Dundee expert has said.

“The challenge is not whether people use AI, but how well they use it” said Dr Michael Crabb, Dundee University’s Head of Computing in the new Faculty of Science, Engineering, and Business.

Dr Crabb says a surge in applications for Dundee’s AI-related courses reflects growing demand from learners who want to remain relevant to modern employers.

(University of Dundee)

“AI is already starting to create a new digital divide,” said Dr Crabb.

“Previously, the digital divide was between people who could access and use digital technology and those who could not.

“Now, however, the divide is increasingly between people who can use AI tools successfully to do what they need to do and those who cannot.

“That does not mean only understanding how to type a prompt into a chatbot.

“AI use is not binary.

“People may use AI for a single task, to support a sustained piece of work, to analyse complex information, to create structured outputs, or to integrate AI into wider workflows. These are very different levels of capability.”

The University delivers more than a dozen AI-related courses across subjects including computing, medicine, biomedical engineering, and business.

Dr Crabb says humans will remain critical to these evolving technologies, with AI creating new opportunities for those who can understand, apply, and develop these systems responsibly.

The growth in applications comes at a time when AI is being positioned as central to the UK’s future economic prosperity and national security.

In April, Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, Liz Kendall, said the UK must build its AI sector and strengthen its capability in technologies that underpin AI.

UK Government Press Release Banner

Dr Crabb said Dundee’s AI provision reflects two linked areas of demand.

Some students want to understand how to use generative AI tools effectively in their future careers, while others want to understand the technologies behind AI systems, including machine learning and large language models.

“AI is a very loaded phrase because public interest in AI is often focused on generative AI and how those tools are used,” he added.

“However, the popularity we are seeing in degree programmes also reflects interest in the development of machine learning and the technologies used to create the large language models and AI systems that are now shaping professional life.

“That is exciting because future students are not just interested in how to maximise the potential of AI systems. They also want to understand how those systems work, how they are developed, and how they can be applied responsibly in different professional contexts.”

Dr Crabb has also been selected for the inaugural Google Higher Education Faculty AI Fellowship, joining a small cohort of academics from across Europe, the Middle East and Africa.

Through the programme, he will explore how universities can move beyond basic AI awareness and develop clearer models of AI capability for students and staff.

He said many institutions lack a clear definition of the AI skills graduates need and how those skills translate to the workplace.

Google AI Fellowship

His fellowship work will focus on creating a practical roadmap for AI capability, helping students and staff progress from basic AI use to more critical, confident and responsible application.

He added that Dundee’s goal is to equip students with adaptable skills such as judgement, verification and responsible use that will remain valuable as AI tools evolve.

For current and future students, the fellowship could influence both teaching and employability.

In the short term, students may benefit from more consistent guidance on how to use AI effectively and responsibly across their courses, rather than receiving fragmented advice from individual lecturers.

In the longer term, the work could help ensure students leave university with a clearer set of AI-related capabilities that employers increasingly expect.

Rather than focusing on specific tools that may quickly become outdated, the emphasis is on transferable skills such as critical thinking, judgement, problem-solving and responsible AI use, which are likely to remain valuable throughout their careers.

The rapid growth of AI has been one of the biggest technology shifts since the rise of the internet.

Tools such as chatbots, image generators and AI-powered search systems are now being used in education, healthcare, business and government, with supporters arguing they can boost productivity, automate routine tasks and help people access information more quickly.

The London School of Economics argue that AI is “degrading the value of a university degree” with Marvin Starominski-Uehara noting that:

“When large language models became widely available, most universities had no rules about them.

“A 2023 UNESCO survey of over 450 universities worldwide found that fewer than one in ten had any formal guidance on the use of generative AI. By 2024, only 13 per cent had published even basic guidance.”

Marvin discusses how a major international survey cited in Stanford University’s 2026 AI Index Report found that 80 per cent of students across 15 countries now use generative AI to help with their studies, double the figure from 2023.

“That sounds like students embracing useful technology. But it masks a serious problem that most students do not understand the tools they are using well enough to use them safely.

“A survey by the Digital Education Council found that 58 per cent of students said they lacked sufficient knowledge and skills around AI.”

As universities come to terms with the rapid adoption of gen AI, the challenge may no longer be whether students use these tools, but whether they understand them well enough to use them responsibly.

For Dr Crabb, the growing gap between AI users and AI-literate users represents a new digital divide.

His fellowship work seeks to close that gap, helping ensure that students leave university not only with access to AI technologies, but with the skills and judgement required to navigate them confidently in their studies and future careers.

The Jute Journal are keen to investigate how much AI plays a role in students studies. Please get in touch, or answer our Instagram poll, with your thoughts or concerns.

Author’s Note

Milne’s Academic interests lie in the Philosophy of Technology. She has written substantially over a prolonged period about the threats of AI and Social Media to the human condition; asking how these innovations can improve and degrade how humans work, act, and be.

Spotted a mistake? Email thejutejournal@dusamedia.com and we’ll look at it. Read our corrections policy.

More from this section

Latest

The weekly newsletter

Every Friday, the week’s stories in one email.